Who’s Handling Your Nonprofit’s Finances? The Hidden Risks of Running Without Staff

For many small nonprofits, passion drives the mission—but resources limit the structure. A 2024 York County report found that 41% of nonprofits with under $50,000 in revenue had no paid staff at all ( KCRA ). Even more telling, a recent analysis in Nonprofit Quarterly revealed that 69% of nonprofits—nearly seven in 10—have budgets under $50,000, meaning most of these organizations are entirely volunteer-run ( Non Profit News | Nonprofit Quarterly) .

 

When no one is dedicated to finances, critical responsibilities fall to volunteer treasurers or overextended executive directors. While this model keeps expenses low, it comes with hidden costs: compliance risks, burnout, and shaky financial oversight.

 

---

The Challenge of Running Without Finance Staff

 

When financial leadership is missing, here’s what typically happens:

• Treasurers get stretched too thin. Most board treasurers didn’t join to spend hours reconciling accounts.
• Executive directors pick up the slack. Instead of focusing on programs and fundraising, EDs spend evenings juggling payroll or preparing IRS forms.
• Volunteers handle compliance. Which often means deadlines are missed, forms are late, or reporting is incomplete.

 

The result? Boards don’t get the clarity they need to make good decisions, and nonprofits take on unnecessary risk.

 

---

The Risks You Can’t Afford to Ignore

• Missed Deadlines: Late 990 filings can lead to penalties or even revoked tax-exempt status.
• Audit Nightmares: Without organized, accurate books, audits become stressful and expensive.
• Donor Trust Issues: Donors want confidence that money is managed well. Disorganized financials raise red flags.
• Burnout at the Top: Leaders already wear multiple hats—adding finance to the mix accelerates turnover and exhaustion.

 

Outsourcing as a Lifeline

 

The good news: nonprofits don’t need to hire a full-time CFO to get reliable financial clarity.

Outsourcing brings in a dedicated accounting team at a fraction of the cost. It’s scalable—whether you’re a grassroots nonprofit just breaking $100K in revenue or a more established organization approaching $1M.

With outsourced accounting, nonprofits gain:

 

• Accurate monthly reporting for board meetings
• Payroll that runs on time, every time
• Support with 990 filings and compliance
• Peace of mind that finances are being handled by professionals

---

Final Word

The nonprofit sector thrives on passion and mission—but mission alone can’t keep the IRS at bay, reassure donors, or sustain leaders through burnout. For organizations without finance staff, outsourcing is more than a cost saver—it’s a safeguard.

At Attolero, we provide accounting, payroll, and treasurer services tailored to nonprofits—so your leaders can focus on changing the world while we handle the numbers.